Egypt: The media and the military

From CPJ:

Substantial setback for press freedom in Egypt

 

New York, April 13 2011- A new requirement by the Egyptian military that local print media obtain approval for all mentions of the armed forces before publication is the single worst setback for press freedom in Egypt since the fall of President Hosni Mubarak in February, the Committee to Protect Journalists said today.  

 

The director of the Morale Affairs Directorate of the Egyptian military, Maj. Gen. Ismail Mohamed Othman, sent a letter dated March 22 to editors of Egyptian publications demanding that they do not "publish any (topics, news, statements, complaints, advertisements, pictures) pertaining to the Armed Forces or to commanders of the Armed Forces without first consulting with the Morale Affairs Directorate and the Directorate of Military Intelligence and Information Gathering, as they are the authorities specialized in reviewing such issues, [in an effort to] ensure the security and safety of the homeland." CPJ has received a photocopy of the letter, and Human Rights Watch reviewed it and confirmed its authenticity.

Last night a journalist friend said a SCAF general had told him that "you can say anything you want in the press, as long as it does not have an impact on the military or the Egyptian citizen." Sounds familiar? That was basically the policy under Mubarak after 2004, when the press could attack the president but these attacks were not allowed to have a political impact. That didn't work out too well, did it?

To be fair, the military has always been a taboo topic in Egypt, even after the partial liberalisation of the media in 2004. What the SCAF generals don't seem to realize is that a lot of taboos are being broken at the moment, and there is an unprecedented thirst for information. 

Comments

[yqxo]

Taboos are not broken unless people demands so, army has shown it is not going to just give these freedoms.

It is well documented that army did torture and imprison protesters arbitrarily during and after protests.

I'm not saying army is all bad -- what I'm saying is army should admit their wrong doings, everyone knows those after all. They try to keep the illusion they are all good and impeccable, when in fact everyone knows this is not true.

[Warren Metzler]

I suggest that this is inevitable. The military obviously saw that its bread was butted by the opposition. But to have supported Mubarak, and before him Sadat and Nasser, all three dictators, all these years has unavoidably created some degree of presumed omnipotence, coupled with their position being a divine right. And that is not going to disappear over night. That is only going to go away with similar, and perhaps more, sustained pressure over time, as was exerted on Mubarak.

But keep up the good work, and in time full democracy, free enterprise and personal freedoms will arrive.

The West didn't get to its current freedoms overnight or effortlessly. It arrived first in the US, but after centuries of struggle, much loss of life, and great inconveniences for most. I am not suggesting your struggle will take centuries, but at least a few years.