Garbage Dreams
Issandr El Amrani
Last night, Ursula and I went to see Garbage Dreams, Mai Iskander's documentary about Cairo's trash collectors (and recyclers), the Zabbaleen. I had wanted to see this movie for months, but it was impossible to obtain on DVD, there were no screenings in Cairo and no one had put it up online — even though it won over 22 awards and, judging from the overflow crowd at Darb 1718, the great cultural center in Old Cairo where it was being shown outdoors in stifling weather, there is much demand for it.
Garbage Dreams follows the lives of a few boys from Mokattam, the hill East of Cairo near which many of Cairo's 60,000 Zabbaleen live and work handling the city's prodigious garbage output. The story of the Zabbaleen is a familiar one, so I'll just briefly repeat here for those who won't know it: they are a mostly Coptic Christian community of dispossessed peasants from Upper Egypt who settled in Cairo in the late nineteenth century and, as a community, became the trash collectors for about 60% of the city. Originally, contracts for trash collection were actually controlled by Bedouins who subcontracted the work to the Zabbaleen. In recent years, not only have they continued to collect trash, but they have also made additional cash from recycling what they collect, impressively reusing about 80% of the trash after sorting it. They live in filthy conditions, amidst their work, but with dignity and, until recently, regular income.
In recent years, the government began contracting foreign companies to use modern trash collection methods. These take Cairo's garbage to landfills and recycle much less of it — only 20% according to the film. This has eaten into the income of the Zabbaleen and is threatening their community, even if some of the workers for the company have been recruited from it. This is an interesting story, but unfortunately Iskander does not tackle it with sufficient diligence: we are given plenty of the Zabbaleen's side of things, but no explanation from the government or the companies about their strategy (which, I'm fairly sure, would have been even more incriminating — the ridiculousness of needing foreign expertise for trash collection is pretty self-evident.)
But perhaps this doesn't matter that much. The heart of the story are the lives of Adham, Nabil and Osama in the context of this threat to the community. They give poignant testimony about their awareness that they are at the bottom of the social ladder, there desire for both mundane and grandiose improvements to their lives, their attachment to their community and pride in its essential work. There are some pretty hilarious scenes, too, such as when the boys are taken to Wales in a NGO-funded trip to look at recycling methods in Europe. In their almost cruel exposure to a clean, green and prosperous Wales (hardly the reputation the country has, say, in London) they see ideas to take back home, but also great waste — there's a great scene in which Nabil lectures the operators of recycling center that they need to be more thorough about separation — essentially by doing the type of manual sorting done in Cairo that is simply impossible under European labor and safety regulations. "Here they have technology, but they don't have precision," he finally scoffs.
The greatest laugh of all for the Cairene audience came when one boy turns to the other at a road crossing, and says with wonder: "Did you see that car? It stopped to let people cross!" That is one other meditation on why Cairo came to be such a badly run city, saved from the total chaos by the hard work and good humor of its underclass.
You can now get the DVD on the film's site or soon on Amazon — highly recommended.
Reader Comments (5)
Fantastic movie---it's a crime that it's not available anywhere. I saw the filmmaker speak at a showing, and you could tell she just has a eye for all the little details that provide characterization, setting, and narrative.
So, is there a way you can petition to get a movie on Netflix?
An amazing film.
I have a copy of the DVD and I also bought a GARBAGE DREAMS' "Recycle T-shirt." I love it and what it three times already and shared it with my kids.
The DVD has 10 mins of deleted scenes, epilogue and a great short film on The Recycling School in the garbage village.
The reason the DVD is only available on <http://www.garbagedreams.com/store/dvd.html> is because the filmmaker wanted to give some proceeds to the Zabbaleen and by selling it on the film's website she is able to do so.
Support this wonderful Zabbaleen community and buy a DVD and T-shirt!
Website www.garbagedreams.com
Karim
I live in US. Are the Copts at bottom of the social order because they're Christians and not Muslims?
TomLa: You find Copts both at the top and bottom of the social order, and everywhere in between. This particular group of Copts came largely from the same area of rural Egypt (which in parts of the south can be heavily Coptic.) But the richest man in Egypt,Naguib Sawiris (who's on the Forbes list of richest people in the world) is also a Copt.
There is discrimination against Copts, but like many minorities around the world they can also occupy privileged social classes. In Egypt, partly because they benefited from missionary Christian education in the 19th century, they are often better educated than Muslims and better represented (proportionally) in certain professions (doctors, pharmacists, etc.). But there are also some terribly poor ones like the ones in Garbage Dreams.
GARBAGE DREAMS DVDs ARE BEING SHIPPED OUT NOW! Check out the full length, theatrical version on the Home DVD, plus EXTRAS like:
Deleted scenes
Updates on the Zaballeen boys
A short film about how The Recycling School works!
http://www.garbagedreams.com/store/dvd.html
A portion of the proceeds go to The Recycling School!