Monday
Aug012005
Protest Detainee Update
By 
Josh Stacher | Egypt
Josh Stacher | Egypt
This post is mostly speculation.
It is based off of rumor and information that is being passed around through phone calls and text messages regarding the cases of the detainees picked up during the anti-Mubarak demo on Saturday.
_______________
What is Known:
First off - there were 24 people detained. According to HR activist Ahmad Saif al-Islam, 2 are in bad shape.
The detainees seemed to have been shuffled back and forth from el-Darrassa military camp to the procesctors and Amn al-Dawla's offices in Masr Gadida. This morning they were sent back to el-Darrassa.
Families and friends of the detained held a sit-in at the General-Proscecutor's office at the supreme court (Dar al-Qada al-Aliya).
Around 430pm this afternoon, the General-Proscetor ordered all of the detained released on bail.
This may, however, only be a small victory.
_________
Sound Rumor:
There is a likelihood that those detained will be charged. I heard the charges that could be levied are:
1) Assaulting police officers
2) Damaging state property
3) Criticizing the government of being corrupt (don't ask me, I don't have a clue about this charges constitutional placement)
4) Holding a demonstration without permission
Naturally, charges 1-3 are suspect. BUT - should the state wish to push this - charge #4 could be used against those recently released.
I am not implying it is fair but it is the way it is unfortunately.
__________
Unsubstantiated Rumor:
There is a story circulating (since last evening) that 8 arrest warrants have been issued to pick up top Kifaya leadership. Kamil Khalil, George Ishaq, and Amin Iskandr were names that were talked about. I have been periodically checking and have not heard that anyone has been served. No one seems to know much about it beyond that.
_________
The Arabist will continue to monitor and update when information is reasonably well confirmed. The situation is, however, very fluid and constantly changing.
It is based off of rumor and information that is being passed around through phone calls and text messages regarding the cases of the detainees picked up during the anti-Mubarak demo on Saturday.
_______________
What is Known:
First off - there were 24 people detained. According to HR activist Ahmad Saif al-Islam, 2 are in bad shape.
The detainees seemed to have been shuffled back and forth from el-Darrassa military camp to the procesctors and Amn al-Dawla's offices in Masr Gadida. This morning they were sent back to el-Darrassa.
Families and friends of the detained held a sit-in at the General-Proscecutor's office at the supreme court (Dar al-Qada al-Aliya).
Around 430pm this afternoon, the General-Proscetor ordered all of the detained released on bail.
This may, however, only be a small victory.
_________
Sound Rumor:
There is a likelihood that those detained will be charged. I heard the charges that could be levied are:
1) Assaulting police officers
2) Damaging state property
3) Criticizing the government of being corrupt (don't ask me, I don't have a clue about this charges constitutional placement)
4) Holding a demonstration without permission
Naturally, charges 1-3 are suspect. BUT - should the state wish to push this - charge #4 could be used against those recently released.
I am not implying it is fair but it is the way it is unfortunately.
__________
Unsubstantiated Rumor:
There is a story circulating (since last evening) that 8 arrest warrants have been issued to pick up top Kifaya leadership. Kamil Khalil, George Ishaq, and Amin Iskandr were names that were talked about. I have been periodically checking and have not heard that anyone has been served. No one seems to know much about it beyond that.
_________
The Arabist will continue to monitor and update when information is reasonably well confirmed. The situation is, however, very fluid and constantly changing.
Reader Comments (1)
according to the lawyers the 8 warrants thing is speculation based on the questions asked in the investigations.
it seems amn el dawla asked each one of the 24 about their relationship with these 8 and thats why people think there could be further arrests.
I would say it is unlikely but this regime stopped using logic a long time ago so anything is possible.
as for charges being unconstitutional, thats hardly the point, it takes a judge to decide and its enough to waste our time until we face a judge.